notid/puzzle-design-kb
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

QA analysis of KQVI puzzle dependencies + fixes

Browse Source 
- Created QA report identifying 5+ invalid dependencies:
  1. Village Phase: S3-S6 shown as sequential but are parallel paths
  2. Five Gnomes: Pearl not gated by gnome solutions
  3. Phase 6/7 ordering: Shield from Minotaur Maze required BEFORE archer
  4. Minotaur internal: S23/S24 and S20/S21 are parallel, not sequential

- Fixed main chart:
  - Village: Show parallel paths converging (S3,S4,S5,S6 → P4)
  - Five Gnomes: Pearl (S12) now independent, gnomes gate north path
  - Phase 6/7: Restructured to show Must do Minotaur Maze FIRST to get Shield
  - Added Phase 6b for return visit with Shield
  - Renumbered all subsequent phases
  - Updated Key Dependency Chains text
This commit is contained in:
Bryce
2026-03-19 18:32:15 -07:00
parent d38c4378f4
commit 4d7b22f3ff
6 changed files with 8764 additions and 0 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

243
src/inspiration/kings-quest-vi-puzzle-dependencies-qa.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,243 @@
# King's Quest VI Puzzle Dependencies - QA Report
## Overview
This document verifies the logical dependencies in `kings-quest-vi-puzzle-dependencies.md` against multiple walkthrough sources. A TRUE dependency exists ONLY when solving puzzle A is a prerequisite for even attempting puzzle B—not merely sequential ordering in walkthroughs.
---
## Dependency Analysis
### Phase 1: Beach
| Dependency | From | To | Status | Explanation |
|------------|------|----|--------|-------------|
| P1 → S1 | Wake on Beach | Pick up Ring & Coin | **VALID** | Items must be collected before anything else can be attempted |
| S1 → P2 | Items collected | Castle guards problem | **VALID** | Cannot prove identity without the ring |
---
### Phase 2: Castle Entry
| Dependency | From | To | Status | Explanation |
|------------|------|----|--------|-------------|
| P2 → S2 | Guards won't let in | Show Ring to guards | **VALID** | Ring is the only proof of identity available |
| S2 → C1 | Ring shown | Meet Vizier, get kicked out | **VALID** | Must see Vizier to trigger exile and subsequent plot |
---
### Phase 3: Village - MAJOR ISSUES FOUND
**Chart shows:** S3 → S4 → S5 → S6 (strict linear sequence)
**Walkthrough evidence:** Items from Pawn Shop (Nightingale, Mint, Flute, Tinderbox, Paintbrush) can be obtained in **any order** after the initial trade. Similarly:
- Getting Magic Map (S4) doesn't require completing S3 first
- Meeting Jollo (S6) can happen before or after other activities
- The ferryman rabbit foot (S5) can be obtained independently
| Dependency | Status | Explanation |
|------------|--------|-------------|
| S3 → S4 | **INVALID** | Sequential walkthrough order, not logical dependency. Map can be obtained before or after other trades |
| S4 → S5 | **INVALID** | Rabbit foot is independent of the map |
| S5 → S6 | **INVALID** | Jollo can be met before visiting ferryman in some play sequences |
**CORRECT DEPENDENCY STRUCTURE:**
The Village activities (Pawn Shop trades, Ferryman, Jollo) are **parallel independent paths** that all feed into accessing the Magic Map. They should be shown as converging to P4 (Isle of Wonder access), not sequential dependencies.
---
### Phase 4: Five Gnomes - ISSUE FOUND
**Chart shows:** S7-S11 (all five gnomes solved) → S12 (Get Pearl from Oyster)
**Walkthrough evidence:** The pearl is obtained from an oyster on the **beach** area. The five gnomes block the path **north** to the interior of the Isle of Wonder. You can get the pearl BEFORE encountering the gnomes.
| Dependency | Status | Explanation |
|------------|--------|-------------|
| All Five Gnomes → Pearl | **INVALID** | Pearl is on the beach and accessible before or after gnomes. The gnomes block northward exploration, not beach access |
**TRUE DEPENDENCY:**
- Five Gnomes → Access to Isle of Wonder interior (north path)
- Pearl → Trade for ring return (separate transaction with pawnshop)
---
### Phase 5: Garden & Chessboard
| Dependency | Status | Explanation |
|------------|--------|-------------|
| P5 → S13 (Flute → Hole-in-Wall) | **VALID** | Must play flute to make shy flowers dance, then grab hole-in-wall |
| P5 → S14 (Iceberg Lettuce) | **VALID** | Can be obtained anytime in garden |
| P5 → S15 (Red Scarf) | **VALID** | Obtained from Chessboard Land queens |
All three lead to P6 (Isle of the Beast), shown correctly.
---
### Phase 6: Isle of the Beast - CRITICAL ISSUE FOUND
**Chart shows:** Phase 6 problems (S16-S21) before Phase 7 (Minotaur's Maze)
**ACTUAL GAME SEQUENCE:**
1. Go to Isle of the Beast
2. **Must** go through Minotaur's Maze FIRST to get the Shield
3. **Return** to Isle of the Beast to use Shield against archer statue
The Shield used in S18 is obtained from the Minotaur Maze (Phase 7), not discovered on the Isle of the Beast.
| Dependency | Status | Explanation |
|------------|--------|-------------|
| S17 (Archer) → S18 (Shield) | **INVALID** | Shield comes from Phase 7, not Phase 6. The chart creates a circular dependency |
**CORRECT FLOW:**
- Enter Isle of the Beast → encounter archer statue (cannot pass without Shield)
- Proceed to Minotaur's Maze (Phase 7) → get Shield
- Return to Isle of the Beast → use Shield to pass archer → continue
The chart incorrectly shows Phase 6 before Phase 7 when Phase 6 actually requires items from Phase 7 to complete.
---
### Phase 7: Minotaur's Maze - INTERNAL ISSUES
**S22 → P8:** Collecting items (Red Scarf, Tinderbox, Hole-in-Wall, Brick) is a true dependency before attempting the maze.
**S23 and S24 order:** The walkthroughs show these can be obtained in **either order**:
- Can get Shield first, then skull
- Can get skull first, then Shield
Both are needed before S25 (Minotaur), but they're parallel, not sequential.
**S20 and S21:** Can be obtained in **either order**:
- Brick is on Isle of the Beast
- Creature with dangling participle is also on Isle of the Beast
Both feed into P7, but they're independent acquisitions.
---
### Phase 8: Logic Cliffs
| Dependency | Status | Explanation |
|------------|--------|-------------|
| S26 (Solve cliff puzzles) → P11 (Dark cave) | **VALID** | Must solve puzzles to reach summit and enter cave |
| S27 (Tinderbox in cave) | **VALID** | Tinderbox enables seeing in dark cave |
---
### Phase 9: Druids
**Chart shows:** S28 → S29 → P13
**Actual requirements:**
- S28 requires Beauty's Dress AND casting Rain Spell
- Rain Spell requires spellbook + ingredients (from multiple earlier locations)
- Beauty's Dress comes from Beast's Domain (Phase 10)
- Scythe and Coal are obtained after/be parallel to S28
| Dependency | Status | Explanation |
|------------|--------|-------------|
| S28 → S29 | **VALID** | Must survive druids before proceeding |
| S29 → P13 | **VALID** | Scythe enables cutting rose hedge |
---
### Phase 10: Beast/Beauty Quest
| Dependency | Status | Explanation |
|------------|--------|-------------|
| P13 → S31 (White Rose) | **VALID** | Must give rose to Beauty before other trades |
| S31 → S32 (Beast's Ring) | **VALID** | Ring obtained after rose introduction |
| S32 → S33 (Mirror/Dress) | **VALID** | Mirror and dress received after proving Beast's intent |
| S33 → P12 (Druids) | **VALID** | Dress needed for druid ceremony; Scythe from druids enables return |
**Note:** This is a loop: P12 (druids) → S28 (survive) → P13 (Beast) → S33 → P12. The dress enables initial survival, not completion of the quest.
---
### Phase 11: Realm of the Dead
**Chart shows:** Strictly sequential P14 → S34 → P15 → S35 → P16 → S36...
**Walkthrough evidence:** The general sequence is correct, but there are **branching points**:
- Zombies (P15) can be avoided OR survived with Rain Spell
- Some items can be obtained in different orders
| Dependency | Status | Explanation |
|------------|--------|-------------|
| Overall sequential flow | **MOSTLY VALID** | General order is required, though some flexibility exists |
---
### Phase 12: Castle Infiltration - BRANCHING ISSUE
**Chart shows:** C4 → P22 → S42 AND S43 → P23
Both paths (paint door vs disguise) are shown converging to P23, but this conflates two distinct entry methods:
**Short Path (Disguise):**
- Get Beauty's Dress
- Enter castle disguised
- Requires: Beauty's Dress only
**Long Path (Paint Door):**
- Get Black Feather + Swamp Ooze + Styx Water + Paintbrush
- Get Spellbook
- Cast Paint Spell
- Requires: Multiple items from across the entire game
| Dependency | Status | Explanation |
|------------|--------|-------------|
| P22 → S42 (Paint door) | **VALID** | Paint door requires many items gathered throughout game |
| P22 → S43 (Disguise) | **VALID** | Disguise requires only Beauty's Dress |
| S42/S43 → P23 | **VALID** | Both lead to guard basement area |
The convergence is technically correct, but the diagram understates how different these paths are.
---
### Phase 13: Final Confrontation
| Dependency | Status | Explanation |
|------------|--------|-------------|
| P27 → S48 (Genie Lamp) | **VALID** | Best ending requires lamp from Jollo |
| P27 → S49 (Mint Leaves) | **VALID** | Alternative to lamp |
| P28 → S50 (Vizier fight) | **VALID** | Cassima's help (with Dagger) enables victory |
---
## Summary
| Category | Count |
|----------|-------|
| **Total Dependencies Analyzed** | ~45 |
| **VALID Dependencies** | ~35 |
| **INVALID Dependencies** | ~10 |
### Invalid Dependencies Found:
1. **S3 → S4, S4 → S5, S5 → S6** (Village sequential order misrepresented as logical dependency)
2. **Five Gnomes → Pearl** (Gnomes don't gate pearl access)
3. **S17 → S18 with Shield** (Circular dependency - Shield from Phase 7 used in Phase 6)
4. **S23/S24 internal order** (Can be obtained in either order)
5. **S20/S21 internal order** (Can be obtained in either order)
### Recommended Corrections to Chart:
1. **Village Phase:** Show S3, S4, S5, S6 as parallel paths converging to access, not sequential
2. **Phase 4:** Remove pearl from gnome dependency chain
3. **Phase 6/7 Order:** Restructure so Isle of the Beast Archer problem requires Shield from Minotaur Maze, showing the Minotaur Maze must be completed first
4. **Minotaur Maze:** Show S23 and S24 as parallel branches, not sequential
5. **Minotaur Maze:** Show S20 and S21 as parallel, not feeding sequentially to P7
---
## Conclusion
The dependency chart captures the **general flow** of the game correctly but contains several categories of errors:
1. **Sequential ordering mistaken for logical dependency** (Village phase)
2. **Missing prerequisite chains** (Shield from Minotaur Maze)
3. **Parallel paths shown as sequential** (Minotaur item collection)
The most critical fix needed is the **Phase 6/7 ordering**—the chart currently suggests you can complete the Isle of the Beast before the Minotaur's Maze, when in reality you must complete the Maze first to obtain the Shield needed for the Archer statue.

291
src/inspiration/kings-quest-vi-puzzle-dependencies.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,291 @@
# King's Quest VI: Puzzle Dependencies
This chart maps the critical puzzle dependencies in Sierra's King's Quest VI (1992), showing which puzzles unlock access to subsequent challenges. Dependencies follow strict necessity rules—a puzzle B depends on puzzle A only if solving A is a prerequisite for even attempting B.
## Puzzle Dependency Flowchart
```mermaid
flowchart TD
%% Start node
START(["START: Wake on Beach"]) --> P1
%% Phase 1: Beach
subgraph Phase1["Phase 1: Isle of the Crown - Beach"]
P1["Problem: Need items to progress"]
S1["Solution: Pick up Royal Ring & Copper Coin"]
end
P1 --> S1
S1 --> P2
%% Phase 2: Castle Introduction
subgraph Phase2["Phase 2: Castle Entry"]
P2["Problem: Guards won't let you into castle"]
S2["Solution: Show Royal Ring to guards"]
end
P2 --> S2
S2 --> C1["Castle: Meet Vizier, get kicked out"]
C1 --> P3
%% Phase 3: Village Setup
subgraph Phase3["Phase 3: Isle of the Crown - Village"]
P3["Problem: Need items and transportation"]
S3["Solution: Trade coin for items at Pawn Shop<br/>- Nightingale, Mint, Flute, Tinderbox, Paintbrush"]
S4["Solution: Trade Ring for Magic Map"]
S5["Solution: Talk to Ferryman → get Rabbit Foot"]
S6["Solution: Meet Jollo in Bookstore → show Ring"]
end
P3 --> S3
P3 --> S4
P3 --> S5
P3 --> S6
S3 & S4 & S5 & S6 --> P4
%% Phase 4: Isle of Wonder - Five Senses
subgraph Phase4["Phase 4: Isle of Wonder - Gnomes"]
P4["Problem: Five gnomes block path north"]
S7["Solution: Give stinky Flower to Smell gnome"]
S8["Solution: Play Nightingale for Hearing gnome"]
S9["Solution: Give Mint to Taste gnome"]
S10["Solution: Give Rabbit Foot to Touch gnome"]
S11["Solution: Use Invisible Ink on self for Sight gnome"]
S12["Solution: Get Pearl from Oyster (from beach, independent of gnomes)"]
end
P4 --> S7
P4 --> S8
P4 --> S9
P4 --> S10
P4 --> S11
S7 & S8 & S9 & S10 & S11 --> P5
P4 --> S12
%% Phase 5: Puzzle Chain on Wonder
subgraph Phase5["Phase 5: Isle of Wonder - Garden & Chessboard"]
P5["Problem: Need items for Beast's domain"]
S13["Solution: Play Flute → get Hole-in-Wall from shy flowers"]
S14["Solution: Get Iceberg Lettuce from garden"]
S15["Solution: Get Red Scarf from Chessboard queens"]
end
P5 --> S13
P5 --> S14
P5 --> S15
S13 & S14 & S15 --> P6
%% Phase 6: Isle of the Beast (initial visit)
subgraph Phase6["Phase 6: Isle of the Beast - Initial Visit"]
P6["Problem: Boiling pool blocks path"]
S16["Solution: Cool pool with Iceberg Lettuce"]
S19["Problem: Need dangling participle for bookworm"]
S20["Solution: Get from creature on Beast shore"]
S21["Solution: Get Brick from garden"]
end
P6 --> S16
S16 --> P7
P6 --> S19
P6 --> S21
S19 --> S20
%% Phase 7: Minotaur's Maze
subgraph Phase7["Phase 7: Minotaur's Maze"]
P7["Problem: Need items to survive maze"]
S22["Solution: Collect Red Scarf, Tinderbox, Hole-in-Wall, Brick"]
P8["Problem: Need Shield and Skull from maze"]
S23["Solution: Navigate tile puzzle → get Shield"]
S24["Solution: Find skull in skeleton room"]
P9["Problem: Minotaur blocks exit"]
S25["Solution: Lure Minotaur with Red Scarf → get Dagger"]
end
S16 & S21 --> P7
P7 --> S22
S22 --> P8
P8 --> S23
P8 --> S24
S23 & S24 --> P9
P9 --> S25
S25 --> C2["Winged Ones give Sacred Water & Oracle Vial"]
%% Phase 6b: Isle of the Beast - Return with Shield
subgraph Phase6b["Phase 6b: Isle of the Beast - Return Visit"]
P6b["Problem: Archer statue kills you"]
S18["Solution: Use Shield to pass archer statue"]
P10["Problem: Rose hedge blocks path to Beast"]
S28["Solution: Cut hedge with Scythe (from Isle of Mists)"]
end
C2 --> P6b
P6b --> S18
S18 --> P10
%% Phase 8: Logic Cliffs
subgraph Phase8["Phase 8: Isle of Sacred Mountain - Cliffs"]
P11["Problem: Copy protection puzzles block summit"]
S26["Solution: Solve cliff puzzles using manual (5 puzzles)"]
P12["Problem: Dark cave blocks path"]
S27["Solution: Use Tinderbox to light way → get Mint Leaves"]
end
P10 --> S28
S28 --> P11
P11 --> S26
S26 --> P12
S27 --> C3["Winged Ones take you to Minotaur Maze"]
%% Phase 9: Isle of Mists / Druids
subgraph Phase9["Phase 9: Isle of the Mists - Druids"]
P13["Problem: Druids will burn you without protection"]
S29["Solution: Have Beauty's Dress + cast Rain Spell"]
S30["Solution: Get Scythe from village"]
S31["Solution: Get Coal from firepit"]
end
P13 --> S29
S29 --> S30
S30 --> P14
%% Phase 10: Beast/Beauty Quest
subgraph Phase10["Phase 10: Beast's Domain"]
P14["Problem: Beast needs help to break curse"]
S32["Solution: Give White Rose to Beauty"]
S33["Solution: Give Beast's Ring to Beauty → get Mirror & Dress"]
S34["Solution: Cut rose hedge with Scythe"]
end
P14 --> S32
S32 --> S33
S33 --> P13
%% Phase 11: Realm of the Dead
subgraph Phase11["Phase 11: Realm of the Dead"]
P15["Problem: Need to reach Land of the Dead"]
S35["Solution: Cast Charm Creatures of Night spell<br/>→ ride Nightmare horse"]
P16["Problem: Zombies block path"]
S36["Solution: Avoid them (or Rain Spell protects)"]
P17["Problem: Need ticket for underworld"]
S37["Solution: Talk to Cassima's parents → get Ticket"]
P18["Problem: Need key to proceed"]
S38["Solution: Play bone xylophone → skeletons dance, drop Key"]
P19["Problem: Need coins for Charon"]
S39["Solution: Take coins from skeleton's eyes"]
P20["Problem: Gate blocks entry"]
S40["Solution: Answer riddle with LOVE"]
P21["Problem: Need gauntlet for Death"]
S41["Solution: Get from dead knight"]
P22["Problem: Make Death cry"]
S42["Solution: Show Mirror → Death weeps → free parents"]
end
S35 --> P16
P16 --> S36
S36 --> P17
P17 --> S37
S37 --> P18
P18 --> S38
S38 --> P19
P19 --> S39
S39 --> P20
P20 --> S40
P21 --> S41
S41 --> P22
P22 --> S42
S42 --> C4["Cassima's parents revived → return to Beach"]
%% Phase 12: Castle Infiltration - Two Paths Converge
subgraph Phase12["Phase 12: Castle Infiltration"]
P23["Problem: Cannot enter castle normally"]
S43["Solution (Long Path): Paint door with magic<br/>- Black Feather + Swamp Ooze + Styx Water<br/>- Paintbrush + Spellbook → door appears"]
S44["Solution (Short Path): Disguise with Beauty's Dress"]
P24["Problem: Guards patrol basement"]
S45["Solution: Avoid or distract with Nightingale"]
P25["Problem: Need to access vizier's secrets"]
S46["Solution: Use Skeleton Key on chest → get Vizier's Letter"]
P27["Problem: Cassima needs weapon"]
S48["Solution: Give Dagger to Cassima"]
P26["Problem: Need Jollo's help for best ending"]
S47["Solution: Befriend Jollo → give lamp replica"]
end
C4 --> P23
P23 --> S43
P23 --> S44
S43 --> P24
S44 --> P24
P24 --> S45
S45 --> P25
S45 --> P27
P27 --> S48
P26 --> S47
S47 --> C5
%% Phase 13: Final Confrontation
subgraph Phase13["Phase 13: Final Confrontation"]
P28["Problem: Genie attacks"]
S49["Solution (Best): Use Genie Lamp (from Jollo)"]
S50["Solution (Alt): Give Mint Leaves to genie"]
P29["Problem: Vizier fights"]
S51["Solution: Use Sword + Cassima's help"]
end
C5 --> P28
P28 --> S49
P28 --> S50
S49 --> P29
S50 --> P29
P29 --> S51
S51 --> END
%% Styles
classDef problem fill:#ffcccc,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
classDef solution fill:#ccffcc,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
classDef phase fill:#e6f3ff,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px
classDef start_end fill:#ffcc00,stroke:#333,stroke-width:3px
class P1,P2,P3,P4,P5,P6,P6b,P7,P8,P9,P10,P11,P12,P13,P14,P15,P16,P17,P18,P19,P20,P21,P22,P23,P24,P25,P26,P27,P28,P29 problem
class S1,S2,S3,S4,S5,S6,S7,S8,S9,S10,S11,S12,S13,S14,S15,S16,S17,S18,S19,S20,S21,S22,S23,S24,S25,S26,S27,S28,S29,S30,S31,S32,S33,S34,S35,S36,S37,S38,S39,S40,S41,S42,S43,S44,S45,S46,S47,S48,S49,S50,S51 solution
class START,END,C1,C2,C3,C4,C5 start_end
```
## Key Dependency Chains
### Long Path (Full Experience)
Magic Map → Isle of Wonder puzzles → Isle of the Beast (initial) → Minotaur's Maze → Isle of the Beast (return with Shield) → Logic Cliffs → Charm Spell → Realm of the Dead → Paint Door Castle Entry → Best Ending
### Short Path (Faster)
Magic Map → Isle of Wonder puzzles → Isle of the Beast (initial) → Minotaur's Maze → Isle of the Beast (return with Shield) → Disguise Entry → Castle → Standard Ending
## Critical Item Dependencies
| Item | Source | Required For |
|------|--------|--------------|
| Royal Ring | Beach | Castle entry, Jollo trust, Sing-Sing delivery |
| Magic Map | Pawn Shop (trade Ring) | Access to all other islands |
| Nightingale | Pawn Shop (trade coin) | Five senses gnomes, guard distraction |
| Tinderbox | Pawn Shop (trade flute) | Dark cave, catacombs level 2 |
| Hole-in-Wall | Isle of Wonder garden | Catacombs spying room |
| Red Scarf | Chessboard Land | Minotaur lure |
| Shield | Catacombs | Archer statue protection |
| Dagger | Minotaur maze | Cassima's defense |
| Beauty's Dress | Beast's domain | Druid ceremony survival, disguise |
| Mirror | Beast's domain | Death's challenge |
| Skeleton Key | Realm of the Dead | Vizier's chest |
| Vizier's Letter | Abdul's chest | Saladin persuasion |
## Parallel Puzzle Paths
The game features parallel paths at several points:
1. **Isle of Wonder exploration**: Five gnomes can be solved in any order
2. **Beast's domain**: Getting brick, meeting creature, and preparing for archers can overlap
3. **Castle entry**: Two distinct paths (paint door vs. disguise) converge at the finale
## Legend
- **Rectangles with sharp corners** (red tint): Problem nodes - obstacles or puzzles that must be solved
- **Rectangles with rounded corners** (green tint): Solution nodes - items collected or actions taken
- **Gold nodes**: START and END milestones
- **Arrows**: Dependency flow (solving A enables B)