notid/e-filing
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

Update prompt to detailed intern-level walkthrough; analyze all 4-part eLegal video

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
Bryce
2026-05-13 11:41:05 -07:00
parent 9bd45ae160
commit 01717a8ece
9 changed files with 362 additions and 19 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

88
docs/research/eLegal_JTI E-Filing Part 1_full_20260513.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,88 @@
# eFiling — UX Analysis: eLegal_JTI E-Filing Part 1_full.mp4
| Field | Value |
|-------|-------|
| **Source video** | `eLegal_JTI E-Filing Part 1_full.mp4` |
| **Duration** | 4m 0s |
| **Analysis date** | 2026-05-13 18:40 UTC |
| **Model** | ~google/gemini-flash-latest |
---
Absolutely. Here is the exhaustive, step-by-step guide for an intern to execute this legal filing workflow.
---
## Step 1: Prepare and Gather Documents
1. **Open the Case Management System:**
* **What you see:** The "Filevine" dashboard. You should see a project titled "10854 - Park Manor Apartments" at the top of the right-hand window.
* **What to do:** Click the "Documents" tab in the left-hand sidebar of the Filevine window.
* **What should appear:** A list of folders. Click the folder labeled "1. Pleadings & Filed Docs."
2. **Download Required Files:**
* **What you see:** A list of PDF files including "CMP - Civil Case Cover Sheet," "CMP - Complaint," and "CMP - Summons."
* **What to do:** Hover over each file and click the "Download" icon (a downward arrow).
* **What should appear:** The files will appear in your browser's download bar or your computer's "Downloads" folder.
* **⚡ Pitfall:** Do not skip any files. You need the Complaint, Summons, and Cover Sheet to complete the filing.
3. **Open the Reference Complaint:**
* **What you see:** Your desktop or downloads folder.
* **What to do:** Double-click the "CMP - Complaint" PDF to open it in a separate window.
* **What should appear:** The PDF viewer showing the legal complaint. Keep this open on the right side of your screen; you will need to copy text from it later.
## Step 2: Initiate the Filing in eLegal
1. **Access the Filing Portal:**
* **What you see:** The "eLegal" Dashboard in the left-hand window.
* **What to do:** Click the large orange button labeled "Initiate a New Case" in the center of the screen.
* **What should appear:** The "New Filing" form with numbered sections.
2. **Select Court and Case Type:**
* **What you see:** Section 1: "Select Court & Case Type."
* **What to do:** Click the "Court" dropdown menu. Type "Alameda" and select "Alameda County Civil" from the list.
* **What should appear:** The selection is confirmed in the field.
3. **Define Case Details:**
* **What you see:** The "Case Type" dropdown menu.
* **What to do:** Click the menu and type "Unlawful Detainer."
* **What should appear:** A list of options. Select "Unlawful Detainer - Commercial (over $10,000 to $35,000) - Civil Limited."
* ⚠️ **Stumble:** If you aren't sure if it's "Limited" or "Unlimited," look at the Complaint PDF.
* 🛑 **Fix:** Look at the top right of the Complaint. It says "Total damages sought are $10,000 to $35,000." This confirms it is a "Limited" case.
## Step 3: Enter Property and Party Information
1. **Enter Location Data:**
* **What you see:** Fields for "Release Zip & Court" and "Premises Address."
* **What to do:** Click the "Release Zip & Court" field. Type "94544" and select "94544 - Hayward Hall of Justice."
* **What should appear:** The court location will auto-populate.
2. **Copy Address from Complaint:**
* **What you see:** The "Address" field in eLegal and the Complaint PDF on the right.
* **What to do:** Highlight the address "27250 Sleepy Hollow Ave, Unit #212" in the PDF. Press `Ctrl+C` to copy. Click the "Address" field in eLegal and press `Ctrl+V` to paste.
* **What should appear:** The text should appear exactly as it is in the PDF. Repeat this for the City ("Hayward"), State ("CA"), and Zip ("94544").
## Step 4: Upload Documents
1. **Select Document Types:**
* **What you see:** Section 2: "Add Documents."
* **What to do:** Click the "Document Type" dropdown. Type "Complaint" and select it.
* **What should appear:** A "Click to Upload" area appears next to the label.
2. **Upload the Files:**
* **What you see:** Your file explorer or the browser download bar.
* **What to do:** Drag the "CMP - Complaint" file from your downloads into the "Click to Upload" box.
* **What should appear:** The filename will appear in green, indicating a successful upload.
3. **Add Additional Documents:**
* **What you see:** An "Add Another" or "+" button (or a new empty row).
* **What to do:** Repeat the process for the "Summons" and the "Civil Case Cover Sheet."
* ⚡ **Pitfall:** Ensure the "Document Type" matches the file you are dragging. If you upload a Summons under the "Complaint" label, the court will reject the filing.
---
## UX Issues Found (severity-ranked)
| Severity | Issue | Where it happens | Why it's confusing |
|----------|-------|------------------|--------------------|
| **High** | Manual Data Entry | Step 3 (Address) | User must manually copy-paste from a PDF to a web form, risking typos. |
| **Medium** | Hidden Logic | Step 2 (Case Type) | The distinction between "Limited" and "Unlimited" requires external knowledge of the dollar thresholds. |
| **Low** | Search Sensitivity | Step 2 (Court) | Typing "Alameda" brings up many results; the user must know to pick "Civil" specifically. |
## Suggested Improvements
1. **OCR Auto-Fill:** Implement Optical Character Recognition (OCR) so that when a user uploads the Complaint, the system automatically extracts the address and damages amount.
2. **Threshold Tooltips:** Add a small "?" icon next to Case Type that explains the dollar amounts for "Limited" vs. "Unlimited" cases.
3. **Drag-and-Drop Bulk Upload:** Allow the user to drag all three files at once and have the system suggest the document types based on the filenames.

83
docs/research/eLegal_JTI E-Filing Part 2_full_20260513.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,83 @@
# eFiling — UX Analysis: eLegal_JTI E-Filing Part 2_full.mp4
| Field | Value |
|-------|-------|
| **Source video** | `eLegal_JTI E-Filing Part 2_full.mp4` |
| **Duration** | 4m 0s |
| **Analysis date** | 2026-05-13 18:40 UTC |
| **Model** | ~google/gemini-flash-latest |
---
Sure! Here are the step-by-step instructions for an entry-level intern to execute the workflow flawlessly:
## Step 1: Prepare and Gather Documents
1. **What you see:** The File & Serve portal on the left and the Filevine document viewer on the right.
2. **Exactly what to do:**
- In the File & Serve portal, look for the "Representing Attorney" field.
- Click the dropdown menu and select "Todd B. Hubbard" regardless of who is signing the case.
- Scroll down to the "Parties" section.
- Click the "Add Party" button.
3. **What should appear next:** A new party entry form will appear.
4. **Where to find the next target:** Scroll down to the "Role" field in the new party entry form.
5. **Exact text to look for or avoid:** Look for "Defendant" in the "Role" dropdown menu. Avoid selecting "Plaintiff" or any other role.
⚠️ **Stumble:** Selecting the wrong role for the party.
🛑 **Fix:** Click the "Role" dropdown menu again and select the correct role.
⚡ **Pitfall:** Forgetting to add all defendants, including those with AKAs or DBAs. The court will reject the filing if any parties are missing.
## Step 2: Input Defendant Information
1. **What you see:** The party entry form with fields for "Last Name", "First Name", and "Address".
2. **Exactly what to do:**
- Refer to the document in the Filevine viewer on the right.
- Copy the defendant's last name and paste it into the "Last Name" field in the File & Serve portal.
- Copy the defendant's first name and paste it into the "First Name" field.
- If the defendant has an AKA or DBA, click "Add Party" again and select the appropriate role (e.g., "AKA" or "DBA").
3. **What should appear next:** The defendant's information will be populated in the form.
4. **Where to find the next target:** Scroll down to the "Party We Represent" section.
5. **Exact text to look for or avoid:** Look for the checkbox next to the party you are representing.
## Step 3: Select Services and Payment
1. **What you see:** Sections for "Additional Services", "Filing Fees", and "Payment Method".
2. **Exactly what to do:**
- In the "Additional Services" section, do not select any services like process serving.
- In the "Payment Method" section, click the "Select Payment Account" dropdown menu.
- Select the appropriate credit card for payment.
- Click the "Calculate Fees" button.
3. **What should appear next:** The total fees will be calculated and displayed.
4. **Where to find the next target:** Scroll down to the "Review & Submit" section.
5. **Exact text to look for or avoid:** Look for the "Submit Filing" button.
⚠️ **Stumble:** An error message appears when calculating fees.
🛑 **Fix:** Review the party information and ensure all required fields are filled out correctly. Check for any typos or missing information.
## Step 4: Review and Submit
1. **What you see:** A summary of the filing information, including the representing attorney, parties, and fees.
2. **Exactly what to do:**
- Review all information for accuracy.
- In the "Courtesy Email Notice" field, enter the project email address found in the Filevine "Vitals" section.
- Check the box "I have verified my filing information".
- Click the "Submit Filing" button.
3. **What should appear next:** A confirmation message will appear, and the filing status will change to "Pending".
4. **Where to find the next target:** The "Filings" tab in the File & Serve portal.
5. **Exact text to look for or avoid:** Look for the filing ID and the status "Pending".
## UX Issues Found (severity-ranked)
| Severity | Issue | Where it happens | Why it's confusing |
|----------|-------|------------------|--------------------|
| Medium | Mandatory Attorney Selection | Step 1, Representing Attorney field | The system doesn't automatically populate the attorney, leading to potential errors if the wrong one is selected. |
| Medium | Manual AKA/DBA Entry | Step 2, Add Party section | Adding AKAs and DBAs as separate parties is counterintuitive and can lead to omissions. |
| Low | Fee Calculation Errors | Step 3, Calculate Fees button | Error messages are not always specific, making it difficult to identify the exact cause of the problem. |
## Suggested Improvements
1. **Automate Attorney Selection:** Pre-populate the "Representing Attorney" field based on the user's login or the specific case.
2. **Streamline AKA/DBA Entry:** Add a sub-field within the party entry form for AKAs and DBAs to ensure they are linked to the correct defendant.
3. **Improve Error Messaging:** Provide more detailed error messages that pinpoint the exact field or information causing the issue during fee calculation.
4. **Integrate Filevine and File & Serve:** Develop a direct integration to automatically pull party information from Filevine into the File & Serve portal, reducing manual data entry and errors.

90
docs/research/eLegal_JTI E-Filing Part 3_full_20260513.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,90 @@
# eFiling — UX Analysis: eLegal_JTI E-Filing Part 3_full.mp4
| Field | Value |
|-------|-------|
| **Source video** | `eLegal_JTI E-Filing Part 3_full.mp4` |
| **Duration** | 4m 0s |
| **Analysis date** | 2026-05-13 18:41 UTC |
| **Model** | ~google/gemini-flash-latest |
---
Absolutely! Here are the step-by-step instructions for an entry-level intern to execute this workflow flawlessly:
## Step 1: Accessing and Downloading Legal Documents
1. **Open Outlook:**
- **What you see:** Your Outlook inbox with a list of emails.
- **Action:** Locate and click on the email with the subject line "Filing ID [ID Number] Accepted on [Case Number] - [Case Name]".
- **Result:** The email content will appear in the reading pane.
2. **Identify the eLegal Link:**
- **What you see:** The email body with a message stating "Your documents could NOT be attached to this email due to the size/count limits. Click here to view your filing and download your filed copies."
- **Action:** Click on the "Click here" link.
- **Result:** A new browser tab will open, leading to the eLegal login page.
3. **Log in to eLegal:**
- **What you see:** The eLegal login page with fields for "Email" and "Password".
- **Action:** Enter your credentials and click the "Login" button.
- **Result:** You will be directed to the "Filing [ID Number] - Accepted" page.
4. **Download Documents:**
- **What you see:** A table under "2. Add Documents" listing various documents (e.g., Complaint, Summons, etc.) with "Accepted" status and a "View" icon (eye symbol) next to each.
- **Action:** Click the "View" icon for the first document.
- **Result:** A "View Document" window will open, displaying the PDF.
- **Action:** Click the "Download" button (downward arrow icon) in the top right corner of the PDF viewer.
- **Result:** A "Save As" dialog box will appear.
- **Action:** Choose a location on your computer and click "Save".
- **Result:** The document will be saved to your local drive.
- **Action:** Repeat these steps for all documents listed in the table.
- ⚠️ **Stumble:** You might accidentally click the "Add a Case" button instead of the "View" icon.
- 🛑 **Fix:** Simply close the "Add a Case" window and carefully click the "View" icon next to the document you need.
- ⚡ **Pitfall:** Do not skip any documents. Ensure every "Accepted" document is downloaded.
## Step 2: Uploading Documents to Filevine
1. **Open Filevine:**
- **What you see:** Your Filevine dashboard.
- **Action:** Search for and open the relevant project (e.g., "19854 - Park Minor Apartments").
- **Result:** The project page will open.
2. **Navigate to Documents:**
- **What you see:** A sidebar with various sections like "Activity", "Property Contacts", "Documents", etc.
- **Action:** Click on the "Documents" section.
- **Result:** The "Documents" page will load, showing a folder structure.
3. **Select the Target Folder:**
- **What you see:** Folders like "1. Pleadings & Filed Docs", "2. Exhibits", etc.
- **Action:** Click on the "1. Pleadings & Filed Docs" folder.
- **Result:** The contents of the folder (if any) will be displayed.
4. **Upload Documents:**
- **What you see:** Your computer's file explorer window with the downloaded documents and the Filevine "1. Pleadings & Filed Docs" folder.
- **Action:** Select all the downloaded documents from your file explorer and drag and drop them into the Filevine folder.
- **Result:** An "Uploading [Number] item(s)" progress bar will appear at the bottom of the Filevine window. Once complete, the documents will be listed in the folder.
- ⚡ **Pitfall:** Ensure you are uploading to the correct folder. Uploading to the wrong folder can cause confusion for other team members.
## Step 3: Updating Case Information in Filevine
1. **Navigate to Dates & Deadlines:**
- **What you see:** The Filevine sidebar.
- **Action:** Click on the "Dates & Deadlines" section.
- **Result:** The "Dates & Deadlines" page will open with various fields.
2. **Enter Case Number:**
- **What you see:** A field labeled "Case Number" under the "Complaint Info" section.
- **Action:** Refer back to the eLegal page or one of the downloaded documents to find the case number (e.g., "23CV106510"). Type this number into the "Case Number" field in Filevine.
- **Result:** The case number is now recorded in Filevine.
3. **Enter Filing Date:**
- **What you see:** A field labeled "Date Case Filed" with a calendar icon.
- **Action:** Click the calendar icon and select the date the case was filed (e.g., "December 19, 2023").
- **Result:** The filing date is now recorded in Filevine.
4. **Verify and Save:**
- **What you see:** The updated "Dates & Deadlines" page.
- **Action:** Double-check the case number and filing date for accuracy. Filevine typically saves changes automatically, but ensure no error messages appear.
- **Result:** The case information is successfully updated, and the workflow is complete.
## UX Issues Found (severity-ranked)
| Severity | Issue | Where it happens | Why it's confusing |
|----------|-------|------------------|--------------------|
| Medium | Indirect Download | Outlook Email | Users have to click a link and log in to another system just to download documents, which is an extra step. |
| Low | Manual Data Entry | Filevine "Dates & Deadlines" | Users have to manually copy and paste the case number and date from one system to another, increasing the risk of errors. |
| Low | Folder Navigation | Filevine Documents | The folder structure can be deep, and it's easy to accidentally upload to the wrong folder if not careful. |
## Suggested Improvements
1. **Direct Attachments:** If possible, configure the e-filing system to include the documents as direct attachments in the email, bypassing the need to log in to eLegal.
2. **System Integration:** Explore integrating eLegal with Filevine so that filed documents and case information (like case number and filing date) are automatically synced to the correct Filevine project.
3. **Drag-and-Drop Target Highlighting:** In Filevine, clearly highlight the target folder when dragging files over it to reduce the chance of uploading to the wrong location.

52
docs/research/eLegal_JTI_E-Filing_Part1_2min_20260513.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
# eFiling — UX Analysis: eLegal_JTI_E-Filing_Part1_2min.mp4
| Field | Value |
|-------|-------|
| **Source video** | `eLegal_JTI_E-Filing_Part1_2min.mp4` |
| **Duration** | 2m 0s |
| **Analysis date** | 2026-05-13 18:38 UTC |
| **Model** | ~google/gemini-flash-latest |
---
Sure! Here's a UX researcher's analysis of the screen recording:
### 1. Overall Workflow Summary
The user is initiating a new legal filing in the eLegal portal, which is integrated with the JTI system. The workflow involves several steps:
1. **Preparation:** The user starts by downloading necessary documents from a case management system (Filevine) and opening a PDF of the complaint to reference key information.
2. **Initiation:** The user clicks "Initiate a New Case" on the eLegal dashboard.
3. **Data Entry:** The user begins filling out the filing details, including selecting the court, case type, and providing additional case information like the zip code of the premises and the amount in controversy.
4. **Reference and Copy-Paste:** Throughout the process, the user frequently switches between the eLegal portal and the PDF of the complaint to find and copy relevant information.
### 2. Friction Timeline
* **0:00 - 0:30:** The user spends time downloading multiple documents individually from Filevine. This is a repetitive and time-consuming task.
* **0:30 - 0:55:** The user opens the PDF and prepares their workspace, which involves manual window management and context switching.
* **1:05 - 1:15:** The user experiences some hesitation and difficulty finding the correct court in the dropdown menu.
* **1:18 - 1:45:** The user spends a significant amount of time searching for the correct case type in a long, unorganized dropdown list. They have to refer back to the PDF to confirm the amount in controversy to determine if the case is "limited" or "unlimited."
* **1:50 - 2:00:** The user has to search the PDF for the zip code of the premises, which involves scrolling and scanning through the document.
### 3. Inferred User Intent
The user's primary goal is to accurately and efficiently file a new case in the eLegal portal. They want to ensure all the information they provide is correct and matches the details in the complaint. They are using a "copy-paste" strategy to minimize errors and save time, but the current UI and workflow are not fully supporting this.
### 4. UX Issues Ranked by Severity
1. **High: Inefficient Case Type Selection:** The long, unorganized dropdown list for case types is a major source of friction and potential error. The user has to manually scan through many options to find the right one.
2. **Medium: Manual Data Retrieval:** The user has to manually find and copy information from a PDF, which is error-prone and time-consuming.
3. **Medium: Repetitive Document Downloads:** Downloading documents one by one is inefficient.
4. **Low: Court Selection Hesitation:** The court selection dropdown could be improved with better search or categorization.
### 5. Suggested Improvements
* **Improve Case Type Selection:**
* Implement a searchable dropdown or an autocomplete field for case types.
* Categorize case types to make them easier to find.
* Provide clear definitions or examples for "limited" and "unlimited" cases.
* **Automate Data Entry:**
* Explore ways to automatically extract information from the complaint PDF using OCR or other technologies.
* Integrate the eLegal portal more closely with case management systems like Filevine to pull in relevant data directly.
* **Streamline Document Management:**
* Allow users to download all necessary documents for a case in a single zip file.
* Provide a way to upload documents directly from the case management system to the eLegal portal.
* **Enhance UI Discoverability:**
* Use clearer labels and tooltips to guide users through the filing process.
* Improve the organization and searchability of all dropdown menus.
By addressing these issues, the eLegal portal can significantly improve the user experience, reduce errors, and increase the efficiency of the legal filing process.